Chapter 3
Amelia’s Point of View
The second time Alessandro Rinaldi walked into my office, Hannah took one look at him and forgot what she was saying.
She'd been lecturing me about working late again, a stack of patient files tucked under one arm.
“Your sacred rule is no appointments after five,” she'd said. “You invented that rule. You used to be very attached to it.”
“I've been flexible.”
“You've been wearing lipstick to work.”
“That is not a crime.”
“And your hair's down.”
“I own hair. Sometimes I let it exist.”
Then the door opened.
Alessandro stood in the doorway in a dark coat, looking as if he'd stepped out of a luxury advertisement designed to ruin my concentration.
Hannah's eyebrows went up.
“Oh,” she said. “Now I understand the overtime.”
“Hannah.”
She gave Alessandro a dazzling smile. “You must be the new patient. Welcome.”
He inclined his head, polite but reserved.
“I was just leaving,” Hannah announced. She lowered her voice as she passed me. “And you and I are absolutely discussing this tomorrow.”
I closed the door before she could add anything worse.
“Sorry about that,” I said.
Alessandro surveyed the room. “Does she always announce what she's thinking?”
“Only the printable version.”
The corner of his mouth twitched.
I indicated the couch. “We have some forms to finish. I don't want to keep treating you without proper background information.”
“Understandable.”
He sounded as though he was indulging a tedious business meeting. I sat across from him and opened his file.
“Marital status?”
“Single.”
A ridiculous little spark of pleasure shot through me. I ignored it.
“Any current medical conditions?”
“Nothing I'm aware of.”
“Medication?”
He took a prescription bottle from his pocket and handed it over. I noted the name and dose, then returned it without making assumptions about the prescriber's reasoning.
“Are you still under the care of the clinician who prescribed this?”
“The person before you arranged it.”
“Before me?”
“Another doctor. A long time ago.”
There it was again: the closed door between us.
“Have you received mental health treatment before?”
“Yes.”
“Can you tell me what kind?”
He stared past me toward the rain-dark window. His fingers pressed together, slowly and deliberately, until the knuckles went white.
“Alessandro.”
“I spent a couple of years in a psychiatric hospital when I was younger.”
I kept my expression steady, though the admission surprised me. “Thank you for telling me.”
“Don't sound so pleased. It wasn't a vacation.”
“I'm not pleased about what happened to you. I'm glad you told me something difficult.”
He looked at me then. Really looked.
“Do you always choose your words that carefully?”
“Only when I want them to mean what I say.”
For a moment the tension shifted. Not gone, exactly. Less sharp.
I set the form aside. “Last time you said your first instinct was violence. I'd like to understand when that began.”
“When I was a child.”
“Tell me about a memory from that time.”
“No.”
I waited.
He frowned. “Aren't you going to tell me I have to?”
“No. I won't force you to relive anything. But I do need to understand how those experiences affect you now.”
He looked down at his hands.
“I remember everything.”
“Everything?”
“Enough.”
“Does remembering feel painful?”
A bitter smile passed across his mouth. “You think pain is the problem.”
“What is the problem?”
“Memory.”
I didn't speak.
“Other people forget,” he said. “They move on. They tell themselves whatever version of the past lets them sleep at night. I can't do that.”
“Because the memories are vivid?”
“Because some of them are mine to answer for.”
An electric silence stretched between us.
I'd seen guilt before, but this was different. He wasn't asking to be forgiven. He seemed to be warning me not to offer forgiveness too easily.
“What happened when you were young?” I asked.
He watched me long enough that I thought I'd pushed too far. Then he leaned back, closing his eyes for a heartbeat.
“There was a drawing,” he said. “I was carrying it down the hallway to show my mother. I heard my father shouting behind her bedroom door.”
My pen remained still.
“Did you go inside?”
“No. I stood there and listened.”
His eyes opened.
“He hit her. And then he saw me.”
I felt an instinctive urge to reach across the space between us. I kept my hands folded instead.
“What did he do?”
Alessandro's gaze moved to the door, as though part of him still expected someone to come through it.
“He crouched down,” he said. “He touched my face. He smiled and told me there was nothing to be afraid of.”
I swallowed.
“And you believed him?”
A laugh escaped him, utterly without humor.
“Doctor, that was the first time I understood a man could terrify you and call it love.”
